How can I compare differently itemised quotations?

    Three quotations, three different layouts, three different totals. A method for normalising them so you are comparing the same job.

    Last reviewed 10 August 2026First published 10 August 2026Written by the TradesChecker editorial team

    The short answer

    Do not compare totals first. Build one list of everything that appears anywhere across the quotations, then mark each quotation as included, excluded or unclear against every line. The gaps usually explain the price difference entirely.

    Step one: build a common line list

    Take a sheet of paper or a spreadsheet. Down the side, list every item mentioned by any of the quotations: labour, each material, waste, scaffolding, parking, making good, decoration, certificates, guarantees. Across the top, one column per contractor. Then mark each cell yes, no or unclear.

    Anything marked unclear is a question, not an assumption. Ask it before you decide.

    Step two: put them all on the same VAT basis

    This single issue causes more apparent price differences than any other. One quotation may include VAT, another exclude it, and a third may come from a business that is not VAT registered and does not charge it. Convert everything to the same basis before comparing, and ask directly where the position is not stated.

    Step three: separate scope differences from price differences

    • Specification: a mid-range and a premium boiler, or concrete and clay tiles, are not the same job.
    • Quantity: check the measurements each contractor has used, since one may have measured the roof or floor differently.
    • Method: full replacement versus repair, or dry ridge versus mortar bedding.
    • Time: a longer programme may mean more labour days, or may mean a more careful sequence.
    • Inclusions: waste, access, making good and decoration are the usual missing items.

    Step four: compare the terms, not just the money

    • Deposit size and payment stages.
    • Guarantee length and who honours it if the contractor ceases trading.
    • Insurance and scheme membership.
    • Start date, duration and what happens if the work overruns.
    • Which certificates you will receive.

    Step five: decide on value, not on the lowest number

    Once normalised, quotations often converge, and a difference that looked like 30% turns out to be 8% plus scaffolding. If one remains well below the others, the usual explanation is something missing rather than a bargain — find out which line it is.

    Our comparison tool does this structurally: enter each quotation and it lays them out on the same basis, flags where the scope differs, and generates the questions worth asking. Nothing you enter is published, and findings are framed neutrally — within or outside the expected range, and what may be missing.

    Questions you can put to the tradesperson

    • “Is your figure inclusive of VAT?”
    • “What measurements and quantities did you price?”
    • “Which of these items have you excluded, and why?”

    These are ordinary questions. A contractor who is comfortable with their pricing will answer them without difficulty.

    Put this into practice

    Compare quotations

    Put two or three quotations side by side on scope, VAT, materials, waste, access and payment terms rather than on the headline total.

    Open compare quotations

    Check My Quote

    Enter the quotation you have received and see whether it sits within or outside the expected range, and what may be missing from it.

    Open check my quote

    Cost calculators

    Build an indicative cost range for your own job and specification before you judge any quotation.

    Open cost calculators

    Sources

    Checked on 10 August 2026. Rules, thresholds and scheme requirements change, so follow the link for the current position.

    General information, not advice on your own circumstances, and not a legal opinion. For help with a specific dispute, contact Citizens Advice or another free independent service.

    All help and protection guides

    Enter the quotation you have received and see whether it sits within or outside the expected range, and which items may be missing from it.

    What you can expect from us

    TradesChecker is an independent UK service. We help you understand a job, sense-check its likely cost and examine a quotation — we do not carry out the work and we do not sell your findings.

    Built for UK customers
    Prices, VAT treatment, certification and regional differences are all based on how work is priced in the United Kingdom.
    Estimates are indicative
    Our figures are a guide to help you plan and ask better questions. They are not a quotation, a survey or a valuation.
    Regional and job factors matter
    Specification, access, location, materials, VAT and site conditions all move real prices — sometimes well outside a typical range for good reason.
    Findings are not for sale
    Commercial relationships never influence what we report about a quotation. No one can pay to change a finding.

    Our assessments are informational and do not replace professional surveying, estimating, building-control or legal advice. How we source our data.